Switching to Cywin-only PIDs introduced a new problem when collecting
Cygwin processes for `ps -W': A process can show up multiple times
again, if the Cygwin procinfo has been opened for a just execing
process. The execed process then shows up twice, once as Cygwin
process, but with the wrong Windows PID of the execing process,
once as Windows-only process.
The mechanism used to exclude these stray processes didn't work with
the new Cygwin pid handling anymore. To fix this
* check if the incoming Windows PID is the same as the PID in the
procinfo. If not, we have the PID of the execing process while
procinfo was already changed,
* always check if the process has already been handled, not only
for processes we got a procinfo for,
* simplify adding pid to pidlist since pid is now always correct.
While at it, fix comments and comment formatting.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
The winpid symlinks got created with no query permissions, so
only admins could see all Cygwin processes. Create symlinks
so everyone has query permissions instead.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
Revert "Cywin: user profile: unload impersonation user profile on exit"
Revert "Cygwin: seteuid: allow inheriting impersonation user profile handle"
Revert "Cygwin: user profile: add debug output to unload_user_profile"
Revert "Cygwin: user profile: Make an effort to unload unused user profiles"
This reverts commit bcb33dc4f0.
This reverts commit dd3730ed9c.
This reverts commit 8eee25241e.
This reverts commit 71b8777a71.
This patchset actually results in the following problem:
- After a couple of ssh logon/logoff attempts, an interactive session
of the same user loging in, is broken.
Apparently UnloadUserProfile manages to unload the user's profile
even while a parallel interactive session still uses the user's
profile.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
When calling spawnve, in contrast to execve, the parent has
to create the pid for the child. With the old technique
this was simply the Windows pid, but now we have to inform
the child about its new pid.
Add a cygpid member to class child_info_spawn. Set it in
child_info_spawn::worker, just prior to calling CreateProcess
rather than afterwards. Overwrite cygheap->pid in
child_info_spawn::handle_spawn before calling pinfo::thisproc.
Make sure pinfo::thisproc knows the pid is already set by
setting the handle argument to INVALID_HANDLE_VALUE.
Also set procinfo->dwProcessId to myself_initial.dwProcessId
instead of to myself_initial.pid for clarity.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
In preparation to protect fork() against dll- and exe-updates, create
hardlinks to the main executable and each loaded dll in subdirectories
of /var/run/cygfork/, if that one exists on the NTFS file system.
The directory names consist of the user sid, the main executable's NTFS
IndexNumber, and the most recent LastWriteTime of all involved binaries
(dlls and main executable). Next to the main.exe hardlink we create the
empty file main.exe.local to enable dll redirection.
The name of the mutex to synchronize hardlink creation/cleanup also is
assembled from these directory names, to allow for synchronized cleanup
of even orphaned hardlink directories.
The hardlink to each dynamically loaded dll goes into another directory,
named using the NTFS IndexNumber of the dll's original directory.
* Makefile.in (DLL_OFILES): Add forkable.o.
* dll_init.h (struct dll): Declare member variables fbi, fii,
forkable_ntname. Declare methods nominate_forkable,
create_forkable.
(struct dll_list): Declare enum forkables_needs. Declare member
variables forkables_dirx_size, forkables_dirx_ntname,
forkables_mutex_name, forkables_mutex. Declare private methods
forkable_ntnamesize, prepare_forkables_nomination,
update_forkables_needs, update_forkables, create_forkables,
denominate_forkables, close_mutex, try_remove_forkables,
set_forkables_inheritance, request_forkables. Declare public
static methods ntopenfile, read_fii, read_fbi. Declare public
methods release_forkables, cleanup_forkables. Define public
inline method setup_forkables.
* dll_init.cc (dll_list::alloc): Allocate memory to hold the
name of the hardlink in struct dll member forkable_ntname.
Initialize struct dll members fbi, fii.
(dll_list::load_after_fork): Call release_forkables method.
* fork.cc: Rename public fork function to static dofork, add
with_forkables as bool pointer parameter. Add new fork function
calling dofork. (struct frok): Add bool pointer member
with_forkables, add as constructor parameter.
(frok::parent): Call dlls.setup_forkables before CreateProcessW,
dlls.release_forkables afterwards.
* pinfo.cc (pinfo::exit): Call dlls.cleanup_forkables.
* syscalls.cc (_unlink_nt): Rename public unlink_nt function to
static _unlink_nt, with 'shareable' as additional argument.
(unlink_nt): New, wrap _unlink_nt for original behaviour.
(unlink_nt_shareable): New, wrap _unlink_nt to keep a binary
file still loadable while removing one of its hardlinks.
* forkable.cc: New file.
Implement static functions mkdirs, rmdirs, rmdirs_synchronized,
stat_real_file_once, format_IndexNumber, rootname, sidname,
exename, lwtimename. Define static array forkable_nameparts.
(struct dll): Implement nominate_forkable, create_forkable.
(struct dll_list): Implement static methods ntopenfile,
read_fii, read_fbi. Implement forkable_ntnamesize,
The arguments are not used anyway, so drop them. When called,
procinfo->dwProcessId is already set right, so we don't have
to access myself_initial.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
Since commit b5e1003722, native
Windows processes not started by Cygwin processes don't have a
Cygwin PID anymore. This breaks ps -W and kill -f <WINPID>.
Introduce MAX_PID (65536 for now).
Cygwin processes as well as native Windows processes started
from a Cygwin process get a PID < MAX_PID. All other native
Windows processes get a faked Cygwin PID >= MAX_PID.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
Using the Windows PID as Cygwin PID has a few drawbacks:
- the PIDs on Windows get reused quickly. Some POSIX applications choke
on that, so we need extra code to avoid too quick PID reuse.
- The code to avoid PID reuse keeps parent process handles and
(depending on a build option) child processes open unnecessarily.
- After an execve, the process has a split personality: Its Windows PID
is a new PID, while its Cygwin PID is the PID of the execve caller
process. This requires to keep two procinfo shared sections open, the
second just to redirect process info requests to the first, correct
one.
This patch changes the way Cygwin PIDs are generated:
- Cygwin PIDs are generated independently of the Windows PID, in a way
expected by POSIX processes. The PIDs are created incrementally in
the range between 2 and 65535, round-robin.
- On startup of the first Cygwin process, choose a semi-random start PID
for the first process in the lower PID range to make the PIDs slightly
unpredictable. This may not be necessary but it seems kind of inviting
to know that the first Cygwin process always starts with PID 2.
- Every process not only creates the shared procinfo section, but also a
symlink in the NT namespace, symlinking the Windows PID to the Cygwin
PID. This drops the need for the extra procinfo section after execve.
- Don't keep other process handles around unnecessarily.
- Simplify the code creating/opening the shared procinfo section and
make a clear distinction between interfaces getting a Cygwin PID and
interfaces getting a Windows PID.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
The new proc fd code accidentally allowed to linkat an O_TMPFILE
even if the file has been opened with O_EXCL. This patch fixes it.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
To allow reopening a file open in another process by HANDLE, introduce
a matching file_pathconv method, taking a file descriptor as parameter.
The result is a serialized path_conv and a HANDLE value. The HANDLE is
valid in the foreign process and MUST be duplicated into the target
process before usage.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
This leads to excessive lag when stracing processes if the inferior
process checks the process table. The reason is that ppid isn't set
in the procinfo memory of the dynamically loading strace itself.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
Returns the process's environment concatenated into a single block of
null-terminated strings, along with the length of the environment block.
Adds an associated PICOM_ENVIRON commune_process handler.
Using PROCESS/THREAD_QUERY_INFORMATION may limit the number of
processes/threads we can inspect depending on their integrity level.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
Revamp device parsing code. Introducing support for more partitions
into the shilka-generated parser has the unfortunate side-effect of
raising the size of the DLL by almost 2 Megs. Therefore we split out
the handling for /dev/sdXY devices into a tiny bit of hand-written
code.
While at it, remove some unused cruft from devices.* and generally
clean up the device class to provide access methods instead of direct
access to members.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
Bump GPLv2+ to GPLv3+ for some files, clarify BSD 2-clause.
Everything else stays under GPLv3+.
New Linking Exception exempts resulting executables from LGPLv3 section 4.
Add CONTRIBUTORS file to keep track of licensing.
Remove 'Copyright Red Hat Inc' comments.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
This reverts commit 0008bdea02.
This patch introduced a regression. Calling FOO=$(...) in zsh hangs
indefinitely and has to be killed forcefully.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
G++ 6.0 asserts that the "this" pointer is non-null for member
functions.
Refactor methods that check if "this" is non-null to resolve this.
winsup/cygwin/ChangeLog:
external.cc (cygwin_internal): Check for a null pinfo before calling
cmdline.
fhandler_dsp.cc (Audio::blockSize): Make static.
fhandler_dsp.cc (Audio_in): add default_buf_info.
fhandler_dsp.cc (Audio_out): Ditto.
fhandler_dsp.cc (Audio_out::buf_info): Refactor method to call
default_buf_info if dev_ is null.
fhandler_dsp.cc (Audio_in::buf_info): Ditto.
fhandler_dsp.cc (fhandler_dev_dsp::_ioctl): Call Audio_out::default_buf_info if audio_out_ is null.
fhandler_dsp.cc (fhandler_dev_dsp::_ioctl): Call Audio_in::default_buf_info if audio_in_ is null.
fhandler_process.cc (format_process_fd): Check if pinfo is null.
fhandler_process.cc (format_process_root): Ditto.
fhandler_process.cc (format_process_cwd): Ditto.
fhandler_process.cc (format_process_cmdline): Ditto.
signal.cc (tty_min::kill_pgrp): Ditto.
signal.cc (_pinfo::kill0): Ditto.
sigproc.cc (pid_exists): Ditto.
sigproc.cc (remove_proc): Ditto.
times.cc (clock_gettime): Ditto.
times.cc (clock_getcpuclockid): Ditto.
path.cc (cwdstuff::override_win32_cwd): Check if old_cwd is null.
path.cc (fcwd_access_t::Free): Factor null check of "this" out to
caller(s).
pinfo.cc (_pinfo::exists): Ditto.
pinfo.cc (_pinfo::fd): Ditto.
pinfo.cc (_pinfo::fds): Ditto.
pinfo.cc (_pinfo::root): Ditto.
pinfo.cc (_pinfo::cwd): Ditto.
pinfo.cc (_pinfo::cmdline): Ditto.
signal.cc (_pinfo::kill): Ditto.
pinfo.cc (_pinfo::commune_request): remove non-null check on "this", as
this method is only called from pinfo.cc after null checks
pinfo.cc (_pinfo::pipe_fhandler): remove non-null check on "this", as
this method is only called from pipe.cc (fhandler_pipe::open) after a null check.
Signed-off-by: Peter Foley <pefoley2@pefoley.com>
winsup/cygwin/pinfo.cc:465:14: error: the compiler can assume that the
address of 'tc' will always evaluate to 'true' [-Werror=address]
winsup/cygwin/ChangeLog
* pinfo.cc (_pinfo::set_ctty): remove always true check.
Signed-off-by: Peter Foley <pefoley2@pefoley.com>
* fhandler.h (class fhandler_base): Convert unique_id to int64_t.
(fhandler_base::set_ino): New protected inline method.
(fhandler_base::get_unique_id): Convert to int64_t.
(fhandler_base::set_unique_id): New inline method taking int64_t.
(fhandler_pipe::fstat): Declare.
(fhandler_pipe::init): Take extra parameter.
(fhandler_pipe::create): Ditto.
* fhandler_socket.cc (fhandler_socket::init_events): Set inode number
to serial number.
(fhandler_socket::fstat): Set device to DEV_TCP_MAJOR. Create st_ino
from get_ino.
* include/cygwin/signal.h (struct _sigcommune): Replace
_si_pipe_fhandler with _si_pipe_unique_id.
* pinfo.h (_pinfo::pipe_fhandler): Take unique id instead of HANDLE.
* pinfo.cc (commune_process): Accommodate change to _si_pipe_unique_id.
(_pinfo::commune_request): Ditto.
(_pinfo::pipe_fhandler): Ditto.
* pipe.cc (fhandler_pipe::init): Take unique id as argument and set
inode number and unique_id from there.
(fhandler_pipe::open): Rework to find any matching pipe from unique
id in filename.
(fhandler_pipe::get_proc_fd_name): Create filename using inode number.
(fhandler_pipe::create): Generate and return unique id from process pid
and pipe_unique_id. In outer method, call init with additional unique
id as parameter.
(fhandler_pipe::fstat): New method.
(pipe_worker): Accommodate using 64 bit inode number in filename.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
* dcrt0.cc (initial_env): Reduce size of local path buffers to
PATH_MAX. Allocate debugger_command from process heap.
(init_windows_system_directory): Very early initialize new global
variable global_progname.
* dll_init.cc (dll_list::alloc): Make path buffer static. Explain why.
(dll_list::populate_deps): Use tmp_pathbuf for local path buffer.
* exceptions.cc (debugger_command): Convert to PWCHAR.
(error_start_init): Allocate debugger_command and fill with wide char
strings. Only allocate if NULL.
(try_to_debug): Just check if debugger_command is a NULL pointer to
return. Drop conversion from char to WCHAR and drop local variable
dbg_cmd.
* globals.cc (global_progname): New global variable to store Windows
application path.
* pinfo.cc (pinfo_basic::pinfo_basic): Just copy progname over from
global_progname.
(pinfo::status_exit): Let path_conv create the POSIX path to
avoid local buffer.
* pseudo_reloc.cc (__report_error): Utilize global_progname, drop local
buffer.
* smallprint.cc (__small_vsprintf): Just utilize global_progname for
%P format specifier.
(__small_vswprintf): Ditto.
* strace.cc (PROTECT): Change to reflect x being a pointer. Reformat.
(CHECK): Ditto. Reformat.
(strace::activate): Utilize global_progname, drop local buffer.
Fix formatting.
(strace::vsprntf): Reduce size of local progname buffer to NAME_MAX.
Copy and, if necessary, convert only the last path component to
progname.
(strace_buf_guard): New muto.
(buf): New static pointer.
(strace::vprntf): Use buf under strace_buf_guard lock only. Allocate
buffer space for buf on Windows heap.
* wow64.cc (wow64_respawn_process): Utilize global_progname, drop
local path buffer.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
* pinfo.cc (_pinfo::root): Fake default root for native processes.
(open_commune_proc_parms): New helper function to access process
parameter block.
(_pinfo::cwd): Fetch missing cwd for native processes from processes
parameter block.
(_pinfo::cmdline): Ditto for command line.
Signed-off-by: Corinna Vinschen <corinna@vinschen.de>
dwProcessId explicitly to handle exec from a windows process.
(winpids::enum_processes): Reorganize to iterate over known cygwin pids when
!winpid. Simplify logic. Don't do duplicate detection for winpid.
/etc/nsswitch.conf file to configure it.
* Makefile.in (DLL_OFILES): Add ldap.o.
* autoload.cc: Import ldap functions from wldap32.dll.
(DsEnumerateDomainTrustsW): Import.
(NetGroupGetInfo): Import.
* cygheap.h (class cygheap_domain_info): New class to keep global
domain info.
(class cygheap_pwdgrp): New class to keep passwd/group caches and
configuration info from /etc/nssswitch.conf.
(struct init_cygheap): Add cygheap_domain_info member "dom" and
cygheap_pwdgrp member "pg".
* cygtls.h (struct _local_storage): Remove unused member "res".
Rearrange slightly, Add members pwbuf and grbuf to implement non-caching
passwd/group fetching from SAM/AD. Make pw_pos and pw_pos unsigned.
* fhandler_disk_file.cc (fhandler_base::fstat_by_nfs_ea): Add RFC 2307
uid/gid mapping.
* fhandler_process.cc: Drop including pwdgrp.h.
* fhandler_procsysvipc.cc: Ditto.
* fhandler_registry.cc (fhandler_registry::fstat): Set key uid/gid
to ILLEGAL_UID/ILLEGAL_GID rather than UNKNOWN_UID/UNKNOWN_GID.
* grp.cc (group_buf): Drop.
(gr): Drop.
(pwdgrp::parse_group): Fill pg_grp.
(pwdgrp::read_group): Remove.
(pwdgrp::init_grp): New method.
(pwdgrp::prep_tls_grbuf): New method.
(pwdgrp::find_group): New methods.
(internal_getgrsid): Convert to call new pwdgrp methods.
(internal_getgrnam): Ditto.
(internal_getgrgid): Ditto.
(getgrgid_r): Drop 2nd parameter from internal_getgrgid call.
(getgrgid32): Ditto.
(getgrnam_r): Ditto for internal_getgrnam.
(getgrnam32): Ditto.
(getgrent32): Convert to call new pwdgrp methods.
(internal_getgrent): Remove.
(internal_getgroups): Simplify, especially drop calls to
internal_getgrent.
* ldap.cc: New file implementing cyg_ldap class for LDAP access to AD
and RFC 2307 server.
* ldap.h: New header, declaring cyg_ldap class.
* passwd.cc (passwd_buf): Drop.
(pr): Drop.
(pwdgrp::parse_passwd): Fill pg_pwd.
(pwdgrp::read_passwd): Remove.
(pwdgrp::init_pwd): New method.
(pwdgrp::prep_tls_pwbuf): New method.
(find_user): New methods.
(internal_getpwsid): Convert to call new pwdgrp methods.
(internal_getpwnam): Ditto.
(internal_getpwuid): Ditto.
(getpwuid32): Drop 2nd parameter from internal_getpwuid call.
(getpwuid_r): Ditto.
(getpwnam): Ditto for internal_getpwnam.
(getpwnam_r): Ditto.
(getpwent): Convert to call new pwdgrp methods.
* path.cc (class etc): Remove all methods.
* path.h (class etc): Drop.
* pinfo.cc (pinfo_basic::pinfo_basic): Set gid to ILLEGAL_GID rather
than UNKNOWN_GID.
(pinfo_init): Ditto.
* pwdgrp.h (internal_getpwnam): Drop 2nd parameter from declaration.
(internal_getpwuid): Ditto.
(internal_getgrgid): Ditto.
(internal_getgrnam): Ditto.
(internal_getgrent): Drop declaration.
(enum fetch_user_arg_type_t): New type.
(struct fetch_user_arg_t): New type.
(struct pg_pwd): New type.
(struct pg_grp): New type.
(class pwdgrp): Rework to provide functions for file and db requests
and caching.
(class ugid_cache_t): New class to provide RFC 2307 uid map caching.
(ugid_cache): Declare.
* sec_acl.cc: Drop including pwdgrp.h.
* sec_auth.cc: Drop including dsgetdc.h and pwdgrp.h.
(get_logon_server): Convert third parameter to ULONG flags argument
to allow arbitrary flags values in DsGetDcNameW call and change calls
to this function throughout. Use cached account domain name rather
than calling GetComputerNameW.
(get_unix_group_sidlist): Remove.
(get_server_groups): Drop call to get_unix_group_sidlist.
(verify_token): Rework token group check without calling
internal_getgrent.
* sec_helper.cc (cygpsid::pstring): New methods, like string() but
return pointer to end of string.
(cygsid::getfromstr): Add wide character implementation.
(get_sids_info): Add RFC 2307 uid/gid mapping for Samba shares.
* security.cc: Drop including pwdgrp.h.
* security.h (DEFAULT_UID): Remove.
(UNKNOWN_UID): Remove.
(UNKNOWN_GID): Remove.
(uinfo_init): Move here from winsup.h.
(ILLEGAL_UID): Ditto.
(ILLEGAL_GID): Ditto.
(UNIX_POSIX_OFFSET): Define. Add lengthy comment.
(UNIX_POSIX_MASK): Ditto.
(MAP_UNIX_TO_CYGWIN_ID): Ditto.
(ILLEGAL_UID16): Move here from winsup.h.
(ILLEGAL_GID16): Ditto.
(uid16touid32): Ditto.
(gid16togid32): Ditto.
(sid_id_auth): New convenience macro for SID component access.
(sid_sub_auth_count): Ditto.
(sid_sub_auth): Ditto.
(sid_sub_auth_rid): Ditto.
(cygpsid::pstring): Declare.
(cygsid::getfromstr): Declare wide character variant.
(cygsid::operator=): Ditto.
(cygsid::operator*=): Ditto.
(get_logon_server): Change declaration according to source code.
* setlsapwd.cc (setlsapwd): Drop 2nd parameter from internal_getpwnam
call.
* shared.cc (memory_init): Call cygheap->pg.init in first process.
* syscalls.cc: Drop including pwdgrp.h.
* tlsoffsets.h: Regenerate.
* tlsoffsets64.h: Ditto.
* uinfo.cc (internal_getlogin): Drop gratuitious internal_getpwuid
call. Fix debug output. Overwrite user gid in border case of a
missing passwd file while a group file exists.
(pwdgrp::add_line): Allocate memory on cygheap.
(pwdgrp::load): Remove.
(ugid_cache): Define.
(cygheap_pwdgrp::init): New method.
(cygheap_pwdgrp::nss_init_line): New method.
(cygheap_pwdgrp::_nss_init): New method.
(cygheap_domain_info::init): New method.
(logon_sid): Define.
(get_logon_sid): New function.
(pwdgrp::add_account_post_fetch): New method.
(pwdgrp::add_account_from_file): New methods.
(pwdgrp::add_account_from_windows): New methods.
(pwdgrp::check_file): New method.
(pwdgrp::fetch_account_from_line): New method.
(pwdgrp::fetch_account_from_file): New method.
(pwdgrp::fetch_account_from_windows): New method.
* winsup.h: Move aforementioned macros and declarations to security.h.
* dcrt0.cc (dll_crt0_1): Use timeBeginPeriod to set default resolution to 1 ms.
* pinfo.cc (pinfo::thisproc): Set ppid for redirected _pinfo blocks too.
(pinfo::init): Avoid using VirtualQuery. Just rely on the assumption that
procinfo will be populated.
* pinfo.h (_pinfo::ppid): Move into redirected block.
* fork.cc (frok::parent): When initializing pinfo for child new PID_NEW flag +
actual defined constant rather than raw number. Don't set start_time here.
* pinfo.cc (pinfo::thisproc): Use PID_NEW when initializing pinfo. Avoid
checking h for NULL multiple times. Don't set start_time here.
(pinfo_init): Aways set ppid last. Tweak strace output.
(pinfo::init): Handle new PID_NEW flag. Wait for shared memory to contain
useful information. Set start_time if PID_NEW.
(_onreturn:h): Define as HANDLE rather than HANDLE *.
(_onreturn::~onreturn): Accommodate h definition change.
(_onreturn::no_close_handle): Rename from no_close_p_handle. Take a pinfo arg
and set hProcess to h before zeroing.
(winpids::add): Don't open a handle to our own process. Change logic
associated with when a handle gets closed. Accommodate no_close_handle
changes.
(winpids::enum_processes): Simplify process enumeration loop.
(winpids::set): Eliminate ill-considered malloc locking.
* sigproc.cc (proc_subproc): Always set ppid last.
using wide chars to make sure native chars don't get scrambled.
* environ.h (build_env): Fix formatting in declaration.
* pinfo.cc (pinfo::status_exit): Handle STATUS_NO_MEMORY. Explain why.
warnings between regparm definitions and declarations.
* smallprint.cc (__small_vswprintf): Conditionalize declaration and
setting of l_opt for only x86_64.
* spawn.cc (child_info_spawn::worker): Remove unused 'pid' variable.
* thread.cc (verifyable_object_isvalid): Temporarily define as
non-inline with gcc 4.7+, regardless of target.
(pinfo::operator == (char *)): Remove unused operator.
* pinfo.cc (pinfo::status_exit): Move this function info pinfo class. Use
progname from the pinfo rather than myself. Be defensive when inspecting
procinfo.
Corinna Vinschen
Michael Haubenwallner
Ken Brown
Erik M. Bray
Peter Foley
Christopher Faylor
Yaakov Selkowitz